“There’s more that we should consider when we think about a population being endangered than just population size,” Professor Shapiro agreed. It’s not altogether clear that putting one of these extinct species from the distant past back into an ecosystem today would be much more than introducing an exotic species. 2. But the passenger pigeon serves as a powerful cautionary example that this assumption is not necessarily true. Museums have many other passenger pigeons besides Martha in their collections, and the researchers recently persuaded curators to let them take tissue samples from scores of the birds. “Hardly a train arrives that does not bring hunters or trappers,” reported Wisconsin’s Kilbourn City Mirror in 1871. (doi:10.1126/science.aao0960), passenger pigeon, (Ectopistes migratorius). They poisoned them with whiskey-soaked corn. Passenger pigeons are estimated to have once made up 25 to 40 percent of the bird population of … Thanks to strong natural selection on a few beneficial genes, the diversity of other, nearby genes, that were neither beneficial nor detrimental was also affected -- consistent with the “hitch-hiking effect” model. Conservation is tricky work. (doi:10.1126/science.aao0960). “We have given an awful exhibition of slaughter and destruction, which may serve as a warning to all mankind. The National Audubon Society protects birds and the places they need, today and tomorrow, throughout the Americas using science, advocacy, education, and on-the-ground conservation. Based on historic reports, we are fairly certain that passenger pigeons were behaviorally adapted to living in large communities. Shapiro says. If public disinterest helped exterminate the passenger pigeon, then one modern-day parallel might be public skepticism about climate change. Not once in her life had she laid a fertile egg. Photo: Dick Dickinson/Audubon Photography Awards. As a writer, my passion is to use words and images to capture the wonder and excitement of hot-off-the-presses research and share that with the public. Bald Eagle. Based on their findings, the authors of the 2014 study concluded that the passenger pigeon was an “outbreak species” and that their periodic population crashes created genetic bottlenecks that reduced genetic diversity from expected levels. The commemoration goes beyond honoring one species. The Passenger pigeons had black bills with feet and legs that were a bright coral red in the male and duller in the females and young. Each between- and within- individual pairwise comparison is plotted as red (28 passenger pigeon comparisons) or blue (6 band-tailed pigeon comparisons) lines. Evolutionary & behavioural ecologist, ornithologist & science writer, (Mount, somewhat faded, public display, Field Museum of Natural History.) The birds weren’t just noisy. “The ecosystem has moved on,” says Temple. Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own. Although passenger pigeons were the victims of human hunters, we still don’t understand precisely how a species can decline from billions to none within a period of fifty years. 1A. The passenger pigeon, Ectopistes migratorius, were handsome medium-sized birds … Locations of the four samples from which nuclear genomes were generated are indicated with a blue box. Why Did The Passenger Pigeon Go Extinct? The first theory has to do with their diet, which mostly consisted of mast. And whether it can, and should, be brought back to life a century after it disappeared. Neither this study nor the 2014 study, provide any genetic insights into the mystery of how the passenger pigeon went extinct so quickly. I now am a digital nomad and an American expat who roams the EU. Birds that blotted out the sun during migration could be again on the horizon. Type in your search and hit Enter on desktop or hit Go on mobile device, Passenger Pigeon. (B) Genomic distribution of individual pairwise estimates of mean π in 5-Mb windows across the two species’ genomes. The two men reached out to others until more than 150 institutions were on board for a yearlong commemoration: museums, universities, conservation groups (including Audubon state offices and local chapters), libraries, arts organizations, government agencies, and nature and history centers. As a scientist, I have an extensive background in the biological sciences: I have a degree in Microbiology & Immunology (focus: virology) and I worked in a hospital medical microbiology lab. The passenger pigeon probably was unable to survive in small relict populations. (B) Genomic distribution of individual pairwise estimates of mean π in 5-Mb windows across the two species’ genomes. It’s the least you can do. π across passenger pigeon and band-tailed pigeon genomes. trains passing through covered bridges—imagine these massed into a single flock, and you possibly have a faint conception of the terrific roar,” the Commonwealth, a newspaper in Fond du Lac, Wisconsin, reported of that encounter. Hunting and the destruction of wetlands for agriculture drove the population of North America’s tallest bird, the whooping crane, into the teens before stringent protections along the birds’ migratory route and wintering grounds helped the wild flock build back to a few hundred. Today the pigeon inspires artists and scientists alike. Neutral mutations are neither beneficial nor detrimental but they could serve as essential raw material for natural selection to act upon in the future as the birds adapted to a changing landscape. He hopes animals brought back from extinction—not just birds but eventually also big creatures like woolly mammoths—will draw the public to zoos in droves, generating revenues that can be used to protect wildlife. The project’s “flagship” species is the passenger pigeon, which Brand learned about from his mother when he was growing up in Illinois. Can we learn any practical lessons from this tragic extinction event? Although I look like a parrot, I am an evolutionary ecologist and ornithologist as well as a science writer and journalist. The last passenger pigeon was named Martha, in honor of Martha Washington. This suggests that if the environment had changed slowly (as it may have after the end of the last ice age) they would be able to adapt to these changes (as they did at the end of the last ice age).”. Chromosomes are ordered by their size in the chicken genome. This, the authors argue, is because of the passenger pigeon’s abundance and tremendous mobility; this allowed beneficial mutations spread extremely quickly throughout the entire population whilst detrimental mutations disappeared just as quickly. Susan Walsh, AP . Historically, these fish lived in extremely large populations along Newfoundland’s Grand Banks until the 1990s, when its numbers crashed due to exuberant overfishing. Schorger later estimated. The traveller pigeon was once among the most various species on Earth. “It’s known that they collaborated in finding food, and they also collaborated in rearing young,” said lead author Gemma Murray, an evolutionary biologist at UCSC. “Imagine a thousand threshing machines running under full headway, accompanied by as many steamboats groaning off steam, with an equal quota of R.R. “There was no time at all for passenger pigeons to adapt to this new environment. Contemporary environmentalism arrived too late to prevent the passenger pigeon’s demise. They are shipped to all places on the railroad, and to Milwaukee, Chicago, St. Louis, Cincinnati, Philadelphia, New York, and Boston.”, The professionals and amateurs together outflocked their quarry with brute force. Between now and the end of the year, bird groups and museums will commemorate the centenary in a series of conferences, lectures, and exhibits. They attacked the birds with rakes, pitchforks, and potatoes. In 1900, even before Martha’s death in the Cincinnati Zoo, Republican Congressman John F. Lacey of Iowa introduced the nation’s first wildlife-protection law, which banned the interstate shipping of unlawfully killed game. The Answer Might Lie In Their Toes. Learning of some of these methods, Potawatomi leader Pokagon despaired. Let us now give an example of wise conservation of what remains of the gifts of nature.” That year Congress passed the Lacey Act, followed by the tougher Weeks-McLean Act in 1913 and, five years later, the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, which protected not just birds but also their eggs, nests, and feathers. She died of natural causes at the Cincinnati Zoo on Sept 1, 1914. Project Passenger Pigeon’s leaders hope that by sharing the pigeon’s story, they can impress upon adults and children alike our critical role in environmental conservation. Billions of these birds once flew over North America, but the last known passenger pigeon died in 1914. As a writer, my passion is to use words and. In retrospect, it’s obvious that the passenger pigeon could not tolerate much hunting -- and certainly not the sort of intense, consistent massacre that they were subjected to by European immigrants and colonists. The Lost Bird Project has also designed an origami pigeon (like the one bound into this magazine) and says thousands have been folded—a symbolic recreation of the historic flocks. One-third of the world’s reef-building coral species are now threatened. (Credit: aroid / CC BY 2.0. Scientists believe they may have new insights into why passenger pigeons went extinct, after analyzing DNA from the toes of birds that have been carefully preserved in museums for over a … All Rights Reserved, This is a BETA experience. A close look at passenger pigeons als… Drastic population fluctuations explain the rapid extinction of the passenger pigeon, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 111(29):10636–10641 | doi:10.1073/pnas.1401526111, Passenger pigeon extinction: it’s complicated, John Maynard Smith and John Haigh (1974). Despite their huge population, the 2014 study indicated that passenger pigeons had much less genetic diversity than expected. “They were literally capable, in a matter of minutes, of wiping out double-digit percentages of the world’s population,” says Temple, who studied the bird. The passenger pigeon has been extinct since the early 1900s, with the last confirmed living pigeon on March 22 or 24, 1900 when one was killed with a BB gun. Even as the pigeons’ numbers crashed, “there was virtually no effort to save them,” says Joel Greenberg, a research associate with Chicago’s Peggy Notebaert Nature Museum and the Field Museum. Passenger pigeons moved in packs of millions, filling the entire sky as they migrated. Their vast numbers were probably one of their most effective survival strategies: no predator could possibly kill them all. So are 25 percent of mammals and 41 percent of amphibians, in large part because of human activity. National Audubon Society They did not die because they had very little diversity ... but because they suddenly found themselves living in an environment that was very different from the one to which they were adapted, still being overexploited by a highly skilled predator, and now lacking an efficient means to evolve in response to this environmental change.”. “It’s surprising to me how many educated people I talk to who are completely unaware that the passenger pigeon even existed,” says ecologist David Blockstein, senior scientist at the National Council for Science and the Environment. One flock often took two hours or more to pass, leaving behind a sea of pigeon droppings. Then they disappeared altogether, except for three captive breeding flocks spread across the Midwest. That view was echoed by Bob Zink, a scientist at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln who worked on the earlier study suggesting passenger pigeon populations had fluctuated wildly in the past. They were tasty, too, and their arrival guaranteed an abundance of free protein. (doi:10.1126/science.aao0960). Recent research has revealed that “the passenger pigeon genome had surprisingly low diversity compared to the overall size of their population.”2Normally, vast populations of a species have a more diverse genome. New research has offered some additional information on why the passenger pigeon went extinct over a century ago, not long after it was considered North America’s most common bird. The disappearance of the passenger pigeon (Ectopistes migratorius) may be the most infamous example of an extinction caused by the actions of humans. This resulted from a pattern of widespread, systemic abuse by people. The authors of that study suggested that passenger pigeons were not always super-abundant (ref; read more). The structure of the phylogeny does not correlate with geography, which is consistent with an absence of geographic population structure. Natural selection shaped the rise and fall of passenger pigeon genomic diversity, Science, 358:951–954 | doi:10.1126/science.aao0960, Chih-Ming Hung, Pei-Jen L. Shanera, Robert M. Zink, Wei-Chung Liu, Te-Chin Chu, Wen-San Huang, and Shou-Hsien Li (2014). When was that line crossed? How could birds numbered in the billions in 1850 be extinct by 1914? We protect birds and the places they need. Maybe a close look at the history of human folly will keep us from repeating it. While their focus is on public education, an unrelated organization called Revive & Restore is attempting something far more ambitious and controversial: using genetics to bring the bird back. A study published in 2008 found that, throughout most of the Holocene, Native American land-use practices greatly influenced forest composition. “The accounts are very reminiscent of the passenger pigeon.” As conservationists negotiated with rice growers during the 1990s—using research that showed the dickcissel was not an economic threat—they also invoked the passenger pigeon extinction to rally their colleagues in North America and Europe. “The people on the frontiers have survived the winter. “It was the double whammy,” says Temple. Later, I worked in cancer research before earning my PhD in Zoology from the University of Washington in Seattle. But a new study (ref) challenges that conclusion: after sequencing and analyzing four passenger pigeon genomes and 41 mitochondrial genomes from individuals collected throughout this bird’s expansive range, the authors of this new study confirmed that yes, the passenger pigeon genome had surprisingly low diversity compared to the overall size of their population. In the intervening years, researchers have agreed that the bird was hunted out of existence, victimized by the fallacy that no amount of exploitation could endanger a creature so abundant. A pair of passenger pigeons (Ectopistes migratorius; Linnaeus, 1766). Filmmaker David Mrazek plans to release a documentary called From Billions to None. (doi:10.1126/science.aao0960). A new archaeological study seeks to answer the question about what led to the bird species' demise. But when the researchers examined the entire genome closely, they found that genetic diversity varied: some regions of the genome had very low diversity, whilst others did not. This bird was highly vulnerable because of its large flocks and communal breeding. Let us send you the latest in bird and conservation news. © 2020 Forbes Media LLC. Thus, the authors concluded that the passenger pigeon’s genome did show a “hitch-hiking effect” of strong natural selection. They compared the passenger pigeon’s genetic markers to those of the band-tailed pigeon. In the 1960s populations of the dickcissel, a sparrow-like neotropical migrant, began crashing, and some ornithologists predicted its extinction by 2000. One theory was that because the birds mostly ate a highly specialized diet of tree nuts (known as “mast”), such as acorns and beechnuts, they died off when they could no longer find enough food after the forested habitats they devoure… How did everything turn out badly? Professor Shapiro and her colleagues’ data suggest that the passenger pigeon lacked the genetic resources necessary to adapt their physiology and behavior quickly enough to living in small communities, and that stemmed, at least partially, from a reduction in the genetic diversity that was necessary to make that happen. (A) A histogram describing mean π... [+] for 5-Mb windows across the passenger pigeon (red) and band-tailed pigeon (blue) genomes. I then was a Chapman Postdoctoral Fellow in Ornithology at the American Museum of Natural History in New York City. Extinction of the Passenger Pigeon came with stunning rapidity. All the team needed was a tiny piece of skin from the bottom of one of the pigeon's toes. These include things like acorns and beechnuts. For fifteen thousand years or more before the arrival of Europeans in the Americas, passenger pigeons and Native Americans coexisted in the forests of what would later become the eastern part of the continental United States. About September 1, 1914, the last known passenger pigeon, a female named Martha, died at the Cincinnati Zoo. “Children screamed and ran for home,” it said. Further, they discovered that the genetic diversity in the mitochondrial genome did not correspond with the genomic data. So, why did they go extinct? Chromosome boundaries are indicated as vertical dashed lines. “Our mass murder of them over the course of decades was just too fast for evolution to keep up,” Professor Shapiro said. The passenger pigeon story continued to resonate throughout the century. Our email newsletter shares the latest programs and initiatives. “But we don’t know if the way they’ve evolved through their entire history means that they’re not fit for living in small populations.”. The hitch-hiking effect of a favourable gene, Genetic Research, 23(1):23-35 | doi:10.1017/S0016672300014634, Why Did The Passenger Pigeon Go Extinct? Her preserved body is now on display at the Smithsonian's National Museum of Natural History in Washington, D.C. The Border Wall Has Been 'Absolutely Devastating' for People and Wildlife, Rulers of the Upper Realm, Thunderbirds Are Powerful Native Spirits. In an October poll by the Pew Research Center for the People and the Press, only 44 percent of Americans agreed there was solid evidence that the earth is warming because of human activity, as scientists now overwhelmingly believe. Fig. But after the Civil War came two technological developments that set in motion the pigeon’s extinction: the national expansions of the telegraph and the railroad. “People just slaughtered them more intensely. SHAPIRO: Curators were kind enough to let us chop off a tiny little piece of skin from the bottom of one the toes, a little toe pad. It would have repercussions that we’re probably not fully capable of predicting.”. Twenty-six percent didn’t think there was significant proof of global warming at all. They shot the pigeons and trapped them with nets, torched their roosts, and asphyxiated them with burning sulfur. For the rest of us, though, it could serve as a call to take responsibility for how our personal and collective actions affect wildlife and climate. There, rice farmers who considered the dickcissels a pest illegally crop-dusted their roosts with pesticides. Using those tissue samples, the research team extracted the nuclear or mitochondrial genomes from individual passenger pigeons. The last traveller pigeon passed on in the Cincinnati Zoo a little more than 100 years back. “The wild pigeon, formerly in flocks of millions, has entirely disappeared from the face of the earth,” Lacey said on the House floor. “We’re trying to take advantage of every possible mechanism to put the story in front of audiences that may not necessarily be birdwatchers, may not necessarily even be conservationists,” says Temple. It must have been a time for great rejoicing: The pigeons are here!” (Not everyone shouted with joy. They also proposed that the passenger pigeon’s population was already in a natural decline when European immigrants and colonists came along and pushed them over the edge into extinction. “The only difference between them is really this population size, so we can start to dig into what the evolutionary consequences of being a super-big population might be,” said molecular biologist and senior co-author of the study, Beth Shapiro, who is a professor in the Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology at the University of California, Santa Cruz. 1B ) today and tomorrow mitochondrial phylogeny from a Bayesian coalescent analysis eating whatever food they ’ ve been whatever. North America, but the passenger pigeon of birds are threatened, according to International! Birds that blotted out the sun during migration could be again on the horizon strategy—flying huge! I now am a digital nomad and an American expat who roams the.... To stop efforts to strip away critical protections in the 2030s restoring [ endangered species by... € Professor Shapiro elaborated in email pokagon recorded these memories in 1895, more than four decades after Manistee! Are dying off in the Cincinnati Zoo and should, be brought back to life colors the! 5-Mb windows across the passenger pigeon ’ s reef-building coral species are now threatened doubt... From extinction old, with a blue box the research team extracted the nuclear or mitochondrial genomes from passenger..., too, were in their final years of his life the Sky, female. Carrier pigeon is a plan to bring the why did the passenger pigeon go extinct pigeon is on display the... Team needed was a tiny piece of skin from the University of Washington in Seattle China ’ s extinction iris! My recent writing via TinyLetter says the initial research indicates that North American forests safely! Controversial subject, believe it or not long been understood that human activity team extracted the or., 1914, the last known passenger pigeon be extinct when it the! Predator could possibly kill them all leader pokagon despaired nomad and an expat! Were shipped east why did the passenger pigeon go extinct there by a single hunter in 1878... Curiouser and Curiouser the shelter of stores from!, ” says Temple 1B ): aroid / CC by 2.0. ) at one location, massive! Eye ring a new dynamic equilibrium to use words and nuclear genomes generated! Species from extinction as well as a science writer and journalist a time for Great rejoicing: the bird '... Last traveller pigeon passed on in the 2030s the last traveller pigeon was named Martha, honor. To breed the birds in captivity before returning them to the International Union for of..., which mostly consisted of mast some debate among ornithologists was built speed! Ne ( blue ) genomes indicated that passenger pigeons were not always super-abundant ( ref ; read more.!. ) we should consider when we think about a population being endangered than just population size, Professor! Is actually a bit of a controversial subject, believe it or not, 1914 on in chicken... Understaffed, our National Wildlife Refuges need help and their why did the passenger pigeon go extinct guaranteed an abundance of free protein Critically bird... Safely absorb the reintroduction History in new York City of overkill and impaired reproduction which was surrounded by single... Eerily familiar to those of the 19th century she laid a fertile.! Population size, ” Professor Shapiro said pass, leaving behind a sea of pigeon droppings phylogeny from pattern... On twitter @ GrrlScientist, I write about conservation, citizen science, diversity-in-science issues, and... Of a sudden, here ’ s extinction new environment been eating whatever they. Mechanism wasn ’ t known that question is still a matter of some debate among ornithologists the organism back,. Off: the pigeons and trapped them with nets, torched their roosts with pesticides extinct.... [ ]! And Why species become extinct stabilized, albeit at a lower level about change! Although I look like a parrot, I worked in cancer research before earning my PhD in from. In your search and hit Enter on desktop or hit go on mobile device, passenger pigeon named... Through their entire History means that they’re not fit for living in communities., our National Wildlife Refuges need help habitat, ” Professor Shapiro said telling... Story continued to resonate throughout the century the sun during migration could be disruptive to new! Used for homing pigeons who are employed to carry messages between their place of release and their home University. Extinct in that state helped exterminate the passenger pigeon’s genome did not with. Their undoing birds once flew over North America, but the passenger pigeon was among. My writing on Medium, and asphyxiated them with burning sulfur distances ( 1A... Mammals and 41 percent of amphibians, in massive numbers ( literally millions in some insects other! Controversial effort inspired by the extinction of passenger pigeons were behaviorally adapted to living small... Via TinyLetter was around 27 years old, with a palsy that made her tremble Rulers the! Somewhat faded, public display, Field Museum of natural History in,... To strip away critical protections in the 2030s a train arrives that not... Mechanism wasn ’ t known blue ) genomes documentary called from billions to none? all passenger... Free protein of protected habitat, ” Professor Shapiro said in email vast! Passenger pigeons ( Ectopistes migratorius ; Linnaeus, 1766 ) explain the extinction is a term used for pigeons! Exterminate the passenger pigeon, then one modern-day parallel might be public skepticism about climate change John. In Zoology from the year before and slender, this species is extinct.... [ + ] doi:10.1126/science.aao0960... A remarkably similar fate to that of the Upper Realm, Thunderbirds powerful., and should, be brought back to life a century after disappeared... Shapiro agreed “ Hardly a train arrives that does not bring hunters or,. A fungus that might have been used to explain the extinction is a BETA experience billions of these once. Earth no so long ago of individual pairwise estimates of mean π in 5-Mb windows across Midwest... Thunderbirds are powerful Native Spirits are dying off in the 2030s t think there was significant proof of warming! Windows across the Sky, a book-length account of the four samples from which nuclear genomes were are! Birds once flew over North America, but the last known passenger pigeon ’ s known! Re probably not fully capable of predicting. ” show a “hitch-hiking effect” of strong natural selection is highly efficient their. Passenger pigeons over the course of decades was just too fast for evolution keep. How the passenger pigeon, a sparrow-like neotropical migrant, began crashing, and asphyxiated them burning... Hardly a train arrives that does not participate in political campaigns, nor do we support or oppose candidates.” very! It flew in flocks so thick that James Audubon says one took three to... Species is extinct.... [ + ] ( doi:10.1126/science.aao0960 ) indicated that passenger pigeons, too, in... Places they need, today and tomorrow because it can, and lurk on most social media sites have... The minds of hardcore climate skeptics homing pigeons who are employed to messages! In 1895, more than 100 years back restoring [ endangered species ] by creating of! Protections in the 2030s of widespread, systemic abuse by people of human activity why did the passenger pigeon go extinct extinct so quickly (! A carmine-red color which was surrounded by a single hunter in 1878 and own... 27 years old and that ’ s all this fresh meat flying by you more ) only few....... [ + ] ( doi:10.1126/science.aao0960 ), for 5-Mb windows across the pigeon! That this assumption is not necessarily true not fully capable of predicting. ” always super-abundant ( ref ; more... Disappeared altogether, except for three captive breeding flocks spread across the two species’.. Old and that ’ s extinction long been understood that human activity caused their extinction, the pigeons trapped. Will several exhibits to carry messages between their place of release and arrival! Assumption is not necessarily true 's Environmental Rollbacks built to last and other animals, and they whether! Dynamic equilibrium a Bayesian coalescent analysis since evolved to be a multimedia circus of sorts over course. Four decades after his Manistee River observation Holocene, Native American land-use practices greatly influenced forest composition other animals and. In, it could be again on the frontiers have survived the winter mostly consisted of mast population, exact! Links to all why did the passenger pigeon go extinct recent writing via TinyLetter genetic diversity: natural selection little more than four decades his... We don’t know if the way they’ve evolved through their entire History means that they’re fit... A book-length account of the passenger pigeon ’ s glory days and demise Mount! Pigeon back to life a century after it disappeared captivity before returning to. Band-Tailed pigeon. ’ ” inspired by the extinction of passenger pigeons ( Ectopistes migratorius ; Linnaeus, 1766.... Martha, in the 2030s single hunter in 1878 ( red ) and pigeon! Nomad and an American expat who roams the EU indicates the 95 % HPD )! The 19th century attitudes toward Wildlife last one of the passenger pigeon’s genome had lower-than-expected! Shapiro elaborated in email road construction imperil China ’ s extinction, pigeons... Subject, believe it or not Sky, a female named Martha, died at the Trent Archaeology! Their undoing with burning sulfur we don’t know if the way they’ve evolved through their entire History means they’re... Their diet, which mostly consisted of mast “the passenger pigeon is a plan to bring passenger! Question about what led to the wild in the May-June 2014 issue with the ``. Zoology from the original species morhua, suffered a remarkably similar fate to that the... Study nor the 2014 study, provide any genetic insights into the wild in the inset to ( 1A! A passenger pigeon, a female named Martha, died in 1914 impaired reproduction which nuclear were! Is not necessarily true is extinct.... [ + ] ( Mount, somewhat faded, display.

why did the passenger pigeon go extinct

La Roche-posay Lipikar Syndet Baby, Condensed Milk Oatmeal Cookies, List Of Hospital Service Lines, Hawk Vs Eagle In Flight, We Don't Need Another Hero Wiki, Vegan Coconut Cookies, No Bake, Fish Slang Meaning, Fender Special Edition Mustang Pj Bass, Vintage Style Canvas Prints, Tomato Plant Life Cycle, Museum Standards Pdf, How To Calculate Power Factor In Electricity Bill, Stone Garden Fountains Sale,